
I have mixed emotions about this album. I thought the band was okay when I heard "Yellow" and was put off a little by how much the press drooled over them. I've always seen Coldplay as a more pop version of Radiohead*. My uneasiness with the band definitely increased with the release of
A Rush of Blood to the Head. It took "Clocks" to embed itself in my head for me to confess liking them enough to buy their CD...a CD that I haven't heard since a few months after buying it. So, yes, I have this CD in my collection, but I've avoided it so much that my listening to it today was just as much as a rediscovery than a technicality to meet my "listen to the album twice before writing a review" requirement.
On this album, Coldplay finds a sound and sticks to it fairly well on the first half. Chris and the band have crafted ballads that are laid atop a rhythm that insists that the listener bob his or her head or shake a fist. Starting with "Politik," the piano, guitars, and drums bang out a beat in the intro and choruses and then sit softly during the verses. Are the drums about to go into "When the Levee Breaks" at the beginning of "In My Place?" Nope, just setting the beat counterpoint for another ballad-like song. After a soft intro with strumming acoustic guitar and Chris's relaxed vocals for "God Put a Smile Upon Your Face", HERE COMES THE BEAT! For me, the piano beat for "Clocks" is what has preserved my appreciation for this song. Despite the solidifying of the "ballad with a beat" as part of Coldplay's sound, there are some good pop hooks that will grab you and have you humming, singing, or tapping along.
Variety does come along in the second half of the album, but it isn't a big change from song to song. Listeners finally get a traditional ballad without the hammer-rhythms of the other songs with "Green Eyes." But I find the second half of the album to be less interesting than the hooks used in the first half.
Songs I knew I liked: "Clocks" and "God Put a Smile Upon Your Face" is really the only song I would readily admit to liking before my listens today.
Songs I didn't know but now like: I had forgotten about "In My Place" and "Daylight" (with its pseudo-sitar guitar sound) over the years.
Songs I can go the rest of my life without hearing again: Pretty much everything in the second half of the album.
* There was something that went around the internet about a decade ago that pointed out how most British rock bands were merely deviations from Radiohead. I believe Coldplay was "Radiohead for people who like U2." I tried finding it just a little while ago, but my Google-Fu wasn't adequate.