I must first declare that I fell in love with Smashing Pumpkins immediately upon hearing Gish. I then proceeded to lose interest in the band as more screamy songs were added to their sound.
Mellon Collie... opens softly, but much of the album contains searing guitar and a sound closer to amped-up prog rock than in previous records. With 28 tracks, be grateful that only a few songs go to prog rock lengths and most are in the 3-4 minute range. The mood shifts back and forth between quiet reflection and loud angst. What moments of happiness may appear in the album seem more nostalgic than hopeful - which is fine if this really is a concept album exploring the various sounds that depression can undertake. But I'm just not buying that the album was a concept as much as they identified a common theme in the songs and tacked the name onto that.
Billy Corgan has a beautiful whisper of a voice, his singing has a whine that works well with many of the Pumpkins songs, but Billy's scream does nothing for me. Most of the songs on Mellon Collie are in the same mold as what you'll find on Siamese Dream. If you love, love, love, Siamese Dream and wish it was longer...here is two more CDs filled with similar songs with some stretching in a softer direction and others going more metal than previous songs. In the end, this is a massive amount of music to process. Forget "Infinite Sadness" the album seemed infinite to me while listening.
Songs I knew I liked: "Tonight, Tonight," "Muzzle," "Thirty-Three," and "1979"
Songs I didn't know but now like: There weren't any songs in the collection that jumped out to me to help overcome my mediocre feelings of most of the tracks. I think "Here is No Why," "Cupid De Locke," and "We Only Come Out at Night" were good songs, but unlike some other songs I've mentioned in this category for previous albums, I don't see myself downloading these songs.
Songs I can go the rest of my life without hearing again: "Tales of A Scorched Earth," "Porcelina of the Vast Oceans" (if it was 4 min instead of 9 minutes long, I wouldn't feel this way), and "X.Y.U."